A Personal Essay & Manifesto – Part 2
For Part 1; Part 3 & Part 4
OPEN PROPOSAL FOR TURKISH & ARMENIAN SYNERGY:
MANIFESTO FOR REVOLUTIONARY RELATIONSHIPS
by Bircan ÜNVER, New York
Dedicated to Devrim/Revolution
[For Part 1]
a “Rehabilitation and Reconstruction Initiative” between Armenia and Turkey,
and between Armenian and Turkish communities around the world
One of my best friends was Armenian. She and I saw each other often until I
left Turkey for America in 1989. At that time there was neither the internet nor inexpensive phone calls,
so I lost contact with her and many other friends.
She and I discussed my nephew’s love story. I sought her opinion about the religious
obstacles he had faced; she gave me a copy of the Bible so that I could
discover the differences for myself. Although I did have copies of the Bible and the Koran, I’d
never read either of them in their entirety.
First Encounter with Armenian-Americans
In 1990 I moved from Tarzana to Glendale in Los
Angeles. Because I had limited
funds, I took English as a Second Language for adult immigrants at a public
school. In a few days, after we
learned a little bit about each other, some middle-aged women approached me and
said, "We know your language.” They were speaking Turkish! Their accent and usage seemed outdated, as in the old Turkish films of
the late 30s, 40s, and 50s. We
talked in class everyday and soon became good friends. At the end of the semester, we had a
class party and each of us brought in a traditional dish from our culture.
These friendly Armenian women felt connected to
Turkey; they were neither hostile to me nor to Turks in general. They were
mature enough to understand the effects of war, and explained matter-of-factly
that “their families were forced to immigrate to Beirut, and later immigrated
to the U.S.” Nowadays, whenever
the Turkish-Armenian conflict rises to the sky, I remember my fellow English
students who cared enough to reconnect peacefully with the people of Turkey.
with Armenians in New York
The next time I was confronted with the Armenian
question was not as pleasant. While
editing a video project at Queen Public TV (QPTV) in New York, I heard some
Turkish-sounding music coming from the next suite. Curious, I went next door, introduced myself, and asked about
the music. The producer said it
was Armenian. Without being aware
of any of the Armenian allegations at that time, I excitedly told him, “I’m
Turkish, and this is very similar to Turkish music!” In an instant, he pointed his finger directly at me and said,
“You killed one million Armenians.” I was dumbfounded and confused. I could only reply, “I just stopped by
to say good morning because of the music,” and left the room.
A few years after this upsetting experience, I
was introduced to two young Armenian brothers at QPTV who had produced “Genocide
– 1915.” In essence, their
program was about blaming everyone who has lived in the Turkish Republic since the
day it was formed by Mustafa Kemal Atatürk (1881-1938) on October 29, 1923. As soon as we were introduced, the
brothers accused me of having killed 2.5 million Armenians.
From my point of view, this kind of allegation
is the product of brainwashed minds, leveled by those ignorant enough to accuse
every Turkish person who crosses their path. This achieves nothing but the destruction of any possibility
for the rehabilitation of the relationship between Turkey and Armenia. Furthermore, I have always thought that
this attitude works against the future of the Armenian people.
believe that both Armenians and Turks were victims of international superpowers during the final period of the Ottoman Empire, and that “the events of April 24, 1915” took place at the peak of its downfall. Because they were already in a state of decline, the Ottomans lost everything in WWI. Then, out of the ashes of war arose the modern-day nations of Armenia and Turkey.
My second positive Armenian-American experience
happened, surprisingly, at QPTV. An Armenian producer, born in Turkey and still
in contact with his birthplace, and I have formed a decent working
relationship. Although we do not
fully agree on some details about the main issue, he remains the only
Armenian-American acquaintance in New York I can describe as moderate. Ever since I launched the Light
Millennium TV (“LMTV”) Series at QPTV, we crew up for each other’s studio
tapings from time to time: one example of an Armenian-American and a Turkish
native working together instead of against each other. I believe that more economic, business,
social, and cultural collaborations will emerge once the Armenian Diaspora
stops suppressing its own people. This
will encourage rehabilitation and reconstruction between Armenians and Turks
around the world.
within the U.N.
Another aspect of the Armenian-Turkish Cold
War, seeded and propagated by the Armenian-American non-governmental
organizations at the United Nations, as well as by the Armenian Mission, is the
effort to obtain a resolution similar to the one concerning the Holocaust of
WWII. Once such a resolution is
obtained, the next step could be to demand compensation. Perhaps a claim for land in the eastern
part of Turkey will follow (ref: the Armenian Constitution and the panel at the
U.N. entitled “Then and Now” on March 30, 2006). These efforts are very troubling, particularly since they
undermine the stated vision of the United Nations.
Despite what others may think about the
Armenian Diaspora’s recent success (the decision of the House of Representatives
– Foreign Affairs Committee, dated October 10, 2007), I believe that the
last 94 years of negativity and destruction have been damaging to Armenians. It cannot help but infuse their children’s future with endless cycles of
Furthermore, not only have both Turks and Armenians suffered greatly since the end of the Ottoman era, but their Cold War has also made American efforts in the “Greater Middle East” less effective. A question we must ask is: who has profited from this long-lasting dark play since the day it was first staged? It seems that no one has shown any interest in examining this and presenting the full truth to the global community, or in naming the producers and directors who pushed the red button that caused the terrible massacres on both sides of the divide. Ordinary Armenian and Turkish citizens were merely the actors in that tragic production. Since then, they have been abused by the politicians who are playing a significant role in this game, and who are responsible for the outcome, “Then & Now.”
(End of Part 2)
- For Part 1; Part 3 & Part 4
Edited by Figen Bingül
Copy Editor: Emily Bunker
Disclosure: This essay was written by Bircan
Ünver as an open proposal to all potentially interested individuals and
institutions/organizations nationwide and internationally, and does not
necessarily represent the opinions of the Board of Directors or the Advisory
Board of the Light Millennium.
Note: The first draft of this manifesto was written
on the 4th of July, 2007, for “a Turkish & Armenian Synergy
Initiative,” to be formed under the Light Millennium Organization, associated
with the Department of Public Information of the United Nations effective on
December 2005. Updated by Bircan
Ünver on November 11, 2007, New York.
“The Light Millennium, is a 501 (c) (3) Tax
Exempt and Public Benefit Organization. http://www.lightmillennium.org - http://www.isikbinyili.org - http://www.turkishgreeksynergy.net - Based in New
York - On the Web since August 1999 – YOU ARE THE SOUL OF THIS GLOBAL
PLATFORM & WE ARE FOR THE GREATNESS IN HUMANITY.”